Kane Simons (TraderKane) is the founder of Prop Firm Compare and a futures trader with 10+ years’ experience. Having earned $3.5M in prop firm payouts, he provides unbiased reviews, comparisons, and insights based on real trading experience.
What are perpetual futures? Compare Nasdaq-100 and S&P 500 perps with
CME NQ and ES futures: funding vs rollover, hours, leverage, liquidation and
regulation.
Compare CFD vs futures prop firms, including position sizing, costs, trading rules and market structure to see which may suit beginner traders.
September 4, 202611 min read
This website uses cookies
We use cookies to optimize your browsing experience, personalize content, and measure the effectiveness of ads. Read our cookie policy.
If you are looking to swing trade futures, the honest answer is that prop firms are not built for it.
Every reputable futures prop firm currently requires positions to be closed before the daily session cutoff. None of the firms reviewed in this guide allow true multi-day swing trading at the evaluation or standard funded account level.
If swing trading is your primary strategy, a personal brokerage account is the better path. Platforms like Tradovate and NinjaTrader give you full control over how long you hold a position, with no session close rules, no consistency requirements, and no firm-level drawdown floors to manage.
Prop firms introduce a layer of risk and restriction that works against swing trading by design. Overnight gap risk, thin liquidity, and higher overnight margin requirements are all reasons why firms enforce daily close rules in the first place.
That said, this guide still has value if you trade futures actively. The five firms below are among the most well-regarded in the space right now. We break down their rules, pricing, and structure so you can evaluate which fits your style: day trading, intra-session holds, or working toward a live account tier that eventually allows more flexibility.
What Is Swing Trading in Futures?
Swing trading means holding positions for multiple hours or days. The goal is to capture larger price moves rather than small intraday fluctuations.
It is different from day trading, where everything opens and closes in a single session. In futures, swing trading typically means holding through the overnight session, across the US open or close, and sometimes over a weekend.
Swing traders need wider stops to account for session-to-session noise. They also need more capital buffer because open positions can move significantly in thin markets.
And they need a firm whose drawdown structure accounts for a position being underwater at 2 AM before recovering by 10 AM.
Can You Swing Trade with Futures Prop Firms?
In the current prop firm space, not really.
No reputable futures prop firm allows true multi-day swing trading at the evaluation or standard funded account level. Every firm on this list requires positions closed before the daily session cutoff.
The reason is straightforward. Overnight positions expose a firm to gap risk, thin liquidity, and margin conditions they cannot control. Simulated accounts are not structured to absorb that kind of exposure.
If your strategy depends on holding positions across multiple sessions, say entering Monday and exiting Thursday, a personal brokerage account through Tradovate or NinjaTrader is a more appropriate setup. You keep full control without session close rules, consistency requirements, or firm-level drawdown floors.
Some firms do allow positions held within a single Globex session, which spans roughly 22 hours. That is not swing trading in the traditional sense, but it does give traders more time in a position than a strict day trading window. MFFU is the clearest example of this.
What to Look for in a Swing Trading Futures Prop Firm
Overnight holding policy. This is the first thing to check. If the firm requires positions flat before session end, swing trading is not possible.
Some firms allow intra-session overnight holds within a 22-hour Globex window. But that is not the same as true multi-day swing trading.
Drawdown type. EOD (end-of-day) drawdown is significantly better for swing traders than intraday trailing. With EOD, your floor only updates at session close.
With intraday trailing, a position that moves against you at 2 AM can breach your account even if it recovers by morning. For anyone holding overnight, EOD drawdown is close to a requirement.
News trading restrictions. Swing traders often hold through major economic releases. A 2-minute blackout around NFP or FOMC can force you to close at the worst possible time.
Check whether restrictions apply to evaluation, funded accounts, or both.
Margin and contract limits. Overnight margin on futures is typically higher than intraday margin. Know the contract limits before sizing a position you plan to hold overnight.
Platform support. NinjaTrader, Tradovate, and Rithmic all handle overnight sessions well. Platform stability matters more than most traders realize until they have a position open at 3 AM.
Swing Trading Futures Prop Firms Ranked
1. My Funded Futures (MFFU)
Evaluation Fee: $50K accounts are currently priced at $126/month (Rapid), $114/month (Pro), and $127/month (Flex) with code LAB. No activation fees on any plan.
Drawdown Type: EOD trailing (Pro and Flex). Intraday trailing (Rapid).
Overnight Holding: Allowed within the Globex session. The trading window runs from 6:00 PM EST to 4:10 PM EST the following day. Positions can be held through the overnight and into the next day's US session, as long as everything closes by the 4:10 PM EST cutoff.
Profit Split: 80% (Pro and Flex) then 90% (Rapid).
MFFU is the most swing-friendly firm on this list in terms of raw rules. The trading window spans roughly 22 hours per session.
A position entered at 6:30 PM can run through the Asian session, the European open, and the US open. That is a meaningful hold window for most setups.
Rule Structure
Core and Pro use EOD trailing drawdown, which is the right structure for multi-session holding. Your floor only adjusts at session close.
Overnight volatility that reverses by morning does not breach the account. Rapid uses intraday trailing, which is harder to manage with overnight exposure. Swing traders should stick to Core or Pro.
There is a news trading restriction on all plans. You must be flat 2 minutes before and after Tier 1 events, including NFP and FOMC. Plan holds around major catalysts accordingly.
Best For: Traders who want intra-session overnight exposure. Intraday-to-next-morning style holds. No activation fees and fast payout processing.
Limitations: True multi-day holds are not possible. Positions must close by 4:10 PM EST daily. No weekend holds. Tier 1 news blackout applies. Core and Pro offer 80% split, below most competitors.
2. Apex Trader Funding
Evaluation Fee: One-time fee. The $50K Intraday Trail account is currently $24.90 with code LAB. Full price is $249. Eval is active for 30 days with no resets. No rebilling.
Drawdown Type: EOD trailing or Intraday trailing, chosen at purchase. EOD drawdown updates once daily at 4:59 PM ET.
Overnight Holding: Not allowed. All positions must be closed by 4:59 PM ET. Apex auto-liquidates any open position at the cutoff.
Profit Split: 100% on the first $25,000, then 90/10.
Apex does not allow swing trading. The no-overnight rule applies across evaluation and funded phases with no exceptions.
A position open at 4:59 PM ET will be auto-liquidated. There is no grace window. If swing trading is your primary strategy, Apex is not the right fit.
Rule Structure
Apex updated its rules in March 2026 with its 4.0 overhaul. Several older restrictions were removed, and EOD drawdown was added as an option, which is a genuine improvement for day traders.
But the no-overnight rule stayed. Dollar-cost averaging is also prohibited on funded accounts. The 50% consistency rule means no single day can account for more than half your total profits at payout.
Best For: Disciplined day traders. Traders who want a large instrument catalog and frequent promotional pricing. Multi-account scaling up to 20 funded accounts.
Limitations: No overnight holds at any stage. Metals futures suspended as of March 2026 with no confirmed return. DCA banned on funded accounts.
3. Lucid Trading
Evaluation Fee: One-time fee. LucidFlex $50K is currently $98 with code LAB, down from $140. No activation fees on any plan.
Drawdown Type: EOD trailing on LucidFlex and LucidPro. Drawdown updates only at end of session, not intraday.
Overnight Holding: Not allowed on evaluation or funded accounts. All positions must be closed by 4:45 PM EST. LucidLive, the live capital tier, allows swing trading and overnight holds, but only after 6 funded payouts.
Profit Split: 90/10 (LucidFlex). 100% on first $10,000, then 90/10 (LucidPro and LucidDirect).
Lucid does not allow swing trading during evaluation or funded phases. Overnight and weekend holds are prohibited across all standard accounts.
The 4:45 PM EST cutoff is 15 minutes earlier than most competitors. Any position still open at that time is auto-liquidated at market.
Lucid does offer a defined path to swing trading. LucidLive unlocks overnight holds, but only after 6 funded payouts. Getting there requires proving yourself as a day trader first.
Rule Structure
LucidFlex has no daily loss limit and no funded consistency rule. That makes it genuinely flexible for day traders working toward LucidLive.
LucidPro uses a 40% consistency rule on funded accounts. No news restrictions during evaluation. Funded LucidFlex accounts also have no news blackout windows.
Best For: Day traders who want no daily loss limit and no funded consistency rule. Traders working toward LucidLive for eventual swing access. Traders who prioritize fast payouts. Lucid averages 15-minute processing.
Limitations: No overnight holds on any evaluation or funded account. The 4:45 PM EST cutoff is earlier than most competitors. Lucid was founded in 2025 and has a shorter track record than others on this list.
4. Alpha Futures
Evaluation Fee: Subscription-based. The Zero Plan $50K is $119/month with code LAB and no activation fee. Standard and Advanced plans start at $79/month and $169/month respectively, but carry a $149 activation fee after passing.
Drawdown Type: EOD trailing on all plans. The Maximum Loss Limit (MLL) is 4% of account size, trailing from end-of-day balance only. Intraday swings do not move the floor.
Overnight Holding: Not allowed. All positions must be closed by 4:20 PM EST. Alpha auto-liquidates at that cutoff. No overnight or weekend holds on any account type.
Profit Split: Starts at 70% (Standard, tiered up to 90%). 90% from day one on Advanced and Zero. Payout caps up to $15,000 per request.
Alpha does not permit overnight or weekend holds. The 4:20 PM EST close is the earliest cutoff of all five firms in this guide.
That reduces your usable afternoon window compared to competitors. If you rely on the late US session, factor that in before choosing this firm.
Alpha's strength is its EOD drawdown structure. The 4% MLL trails only from daily close, not intraday equity peaks. Large intraday swings that recover by session end do not affect your floor.
The firm holds a 4.9/5 Trustpilot rating from over 2,600 reviews, the highest of any futures prop firm reviewed here.
Rule Structure
Standard and Zero funded accounts face a 2-minute news blackout before and after high-impact events. Advanced funded accounts have no news restrictions. All plans allow news trading freely during evaluation.
Advanced removes the funded consistency rule entirely, making it the most flexible option for experienced traders.
Best For: Day traders who want the most forgiving EOD drawdown in the space. Advanced plan holders who want no funded consistency rule and unrestricted news trading. Traders who weight Trustpilot track record heavily.
Limitations: No overnight or weekend holds. Subscription pricing means costs accumulate if evaluation runs long. The $149 activation fee adds to total cost on Standard and Advanced. Standard plan starts at 70% split.
5. Tradeify
Evaluation Fee: One-time fee. Select 50K is currently $99 with code LAB, down from $165. Growth 50K is $65 with the same code. No activation fees on any plan.
Drawdown Type: EOD trailing on all account families. Drawdown locks permanently once your balance clears starting capital plus $100.
Overnight Holding: Not allowed on any account type or phase. All positions must be closed by 4:59 PM ET. Tradeify auto-liquidates open positions at the close. This rule applies to evaluation, funded, and Elite live accounts.
Profit Split: 90% on Select accounts from payout one. Growth and Lightning offer 100% on the first $15,000, then 90%.
Tradeify does not allow swing trading. The no-overnight rule is firm-wide and applies even at the Elite live tier.
But for day traders, the rest of the rule set is clean. No news restrictions on any account. No daily loss limit on Select Flex funded accounts. EOD drawdown with a permanently locking floor once you build enough profit.
The Select plan also has a unique structure. You complete the evaluation first, then choose between daily payouts or 5-day flex cycles based on your actual performance.
Rule Structure
Select accounts have a 40% consistency rule during evaluation but none once funded on the Flex path. Growth accounts have no evaluation consistency rule but a 35% rule once funded.
Lightning (instant funded) comes with a progressive consistency rule that increases with each payout. No news blackout on any account or phase.
Best For: Day traders who want EOD drawdown with a locking floor and no news restrictions. One-time pricing with no activation fee. Traders building toward Tradeify Elite live accounts.
Limitations: No overnight holds at any stage, including live accounts. Select evaluation requires at least 3 trading days. Lightning drawdown tightened in the 3.0 update. Platform selection is locked at checkout.
Quick Comparison for Swing Traders
Use the table below to compare the five firms at a glance. Overnight holding is the defining column for swing traders. Drawdown type is the second thing to check. EOD is significantly more forgiving than intraday trailing for anyone holding through volatile sessions.
Clean rules, no news restrictions, flexible payouts
Why Most Futures Prop Firms Restrict Swing Trading
The reason most firms prohibit overnight holding comes down to their own risk exposure.
Overnight futures positions create gap risk. A position held through the close can gap significantly at the next session open due to earnings, geopolitical events, or economic data released after US hours.
Prop firms using simulated accounts cannot manage this the way a live brokerage can. An unmanaged overnight gap can breach an account in a way that cannot be walked back.
Overnight sessions also carry thinner liquidity. CME products trade around the clock, but volume drops sharply between the US close and the Asian open.
Forced liquidations in illiquid conditions create slippage that most prop firm drawdown structures are not calibrated to absorb.
There is also the margin issue. CME exchanges set higher overnight margin requirements than intraday margins. Most prop firms calibrate their contract limits around intraday parameters, not overnight ones.
Allowing overnight holds without adjusting for this creates asymmetric risk. Most firms choose to avoid it.
How Drawdown Rules Impact Swing Trading
This section matters even if your firm technically allows overnight holds.
Trailing drawdown. Most prop firms use trailing drawdown that follows your equity upward. If you build a $3,000 profit cushion during the day, your floor moves up by $3,000.
On an intraday trailing model, the floor moves in real time. A position running in your favor at 6 PM sets a new floor. Any overnight reversal needs to stay above it.
On EOD trailing, the floor only updates at session close. That gives you real room to manage trades through overnight volatility without getting breached on a temporary move.
Intraday liquidation on funded accounts. Some firms use EOD drawdown during evaluation but switch to tighter intraday rules once funded. Always read the funded phase rules separately. They are not always the same.
Volatility across sessions. The Asian session is thin and prone to sharp false moves. European data can create a 6-8 AM spike that fully reverses by the US open.
If you are holding overnight on MFFU's Rapid plan, that intraday spike affects your floor in real time. On Core or Pro, it does not. Know your plan before sizing an overnight position.
How to Swing Trade Within Prop Firm Rules
If your firm limits overnight holds to a single session window, there are still ways to capture multi-hour moves without breaking rules.
Use the full session window. MFFU's window runs from 6:00 PM to 4:10 PM the next day. That is nearly 22 hours. A position entered during the London session can run through the US open and well into the afternoon.
Reduce position size for overnight holds. Thin liquidity and wider spreads increase slippage risk overnight. A smaller position with a wider stop is less likely to get stopped out on noise.
Plan around news events. If your firm has a blackout window, factor that into your hold. Holding through NFP with a 2-minute restriction means being flat before 8:28 AM EST, or avoiding entries near that window entirely.
Set alerts for session close. Auto-liquidation is not a safety net. Slippage from a forced close can damage your P&L, especially on instruments like NQ. Close manually 5-10 minutes before the cutoff.
Avoid weekends. No firm on this list allows weekend holds at the evaluation or funded tier. If you are in a trade Friday afternoon, it closes before the Friday cutoff regardless of where the position sits.
Is Swing Trading Suitable for Prop Firm Challenges?
In short, no. Not in the current prop firm landscape.
Every firm on this list requires positions closed before the daily session cutoff. True multi-day swing trading is not available at the evaluation or standard funded account level. The prop firm model is built around intraday performance, and the rules reflect that.
If swing trading is your strategy, a personal brokerage account is the more appropriate vehicle. Platforms like Tradovate and NinjaTrader give you direct CME market access with no session close rules and no firm-level restrictions on how long you hold a position.
That said, there are still elements of a swing-oriented approach that can apply within prop firm rules. Patience, wider stops, and fewer trades can help you avoid the overtrading that burns most evaluation accounts. Holding through the overnight portion of a single Globex session on MFFU is also possible, which gives more time in a position than a strict day trading window.
But these are adaptations, not swing trading. If your edge depends on multi-day holds, prop firms are the wrong tool for it.
Prop Firm Compare's Final Verdict
None of the five firms reviewed here support swing trading. That is not a criticism of these firms. It reflects how the prop firm model works.
Overnight gap risk, thin liquidity, and higher overnight margin requirements make multi-day holds incompatible with most prop firm structures. These rules exist for a reason.
If swing trading is your strategy, open a personal futures account. Tradovate and NinjaTrader both offer direct access to CME markets with no session close rules, no consistency requirements, and no firm-level drawdown to manage. You trade your own capital, on your own terms.
For traders who want funded futures exposure and are comfortable with intraday or intra-session trading, these five firms are worth considering. If you want intra-session overnight flexibility, MFFU is the clearest choice.
If you want clean day trading rules and flexible payout options, Tradeify and Lucid are both strong. For the most forgiving EOD drawdown, Alpha Futures stands out. And if promotional pricing and a large instrument catalog matter most, Apex is the most accessible firm on this list.
Before signing up with any firm, verify current rules and pricing directly on their website. Rules change frequently, and this guide reflects April 2026 information.
Not at any reputable firm right now. Every firm reviewed here requires positions closed before the daily session cutoff.
True multi-day swing trading is not viable in the current prop firm space. If swing trading is your primary approach, a personal brokerage account through Tradovate or NinjaTrader is the more practical option. You get full control over hold times without session close rules or firm-level drawdown floors.
MFFU offers the closest thing to extended hold time, with a session window from 6:00 PM to 4:10 PM EST the following day. But that is still a single-session window, not multi-day swing trading.
Which prop firms allow overnight holding?
Of the firms reviewed here, MFFU comes closest. Their session window spans 6:00 PM to 4:10 PM EST the next day, so positions can run through the overnight and into the following afternoon.
No firm on this list allows holding past the daily session close or over weekends at the standard evaluation or funded tier. Lucid's LucidLive tier allows overnight exposure, but that requires 6 funded payouts to reach.
Is swing trading harder with prop firms?
Yes, for most firms. The daily close requirement means you cannot let trades run across multiple sessions. That removes one of swing trading's core advantages.
You also need to plan around news blackouts, consistency rules, and drawdown structures that may not account for overnight volatility. The firms closest to a swing-friendly setup still require day trading first during evaluation and early funded stages.
What drawdown type is best for swing trading?
EOD (end-of-day) trailing drawdown is the clear choice. Your floor only adjusts at session close. Intraday price moves do not affect it.
This matters for anyone holding through the overnight session. A position down at 2 AM that recovers by the US open has no effect on your account under an EOD model. Intraday trailing can breach an account during a normal overnight swing before you have a chance to respond.
Can you hold trades over the weekend?
No. None of the five firms on this list allow weekend holds at the evaluation or standard funded tier. All positions must be closed before the Friday session cutoff.
Trading resumes when the Globex session reopens Sunday evening. If you are still in a trade Friday afternoon, it will be auto-liquidated or you are responsible for closing it before the cutoff.
Do prop firms restrict news trading?
Most do to some extent. MFFU requires you to be flat 2 minutes before and after Tier 1 events on all plans. Alpha Futures restricts entries within a 2-minute window around high-impact events on Standard and Zero funded accounts. Advanced accounts at Alpha have no restrictions.
Tradeify has no news restrictions on any account or phase. Lucid's LucidFlex funded accounts also have no blackout windows. Apex allows news trading but prohibits straddles and setups designed purely to bet on a release direction.
Is swing trading profitable in futures?
It can be. But it is much easier to execute in a personal brokerage account than at a prop firm.
The main edges of swing trading, holding winners for days, avoiding daily noise, and capturing trend moves, are largely unavailable in the prop firm model. Session close rules, consistency requirements, and daily drawdown floors all work against a multi-day strategy.
If swing trading is your edge, trade your own capital through a platform like Tradovate or NinjaTrader. Prop firms are built for intraday performance. Forcing a swing strategy into that structure creates unnecessary friction and risk.
